Real-Time Resource Allocation
EN

What the high cost of living has to do with the market economy

Diesen Beitrag auf Deutsch lesen →

Street-art-style collage: the face of a young person with raised fists in front of newspaper pages, painted over with bright colours and lettering
stock.adobe.com

For days now, people in France and Italy have been taking to the streets, in part over the high cost of living. Alongside the protests there have been serious riots and looting. Both governments have responded with night-time curfews and extra soldiers in city centres. The images reported by the German news programme Tagesschau are reminiscent of dystopian films.

Soldiers, curfews, decrees

How France and Italy are responding to the riots

“Curfews, anti-terror soldiers, new decrees: France and Italy have responded to the weekend’s riots. The aim is to prevent unrest in future.”

When the money no longer stretches

A high cost of living means one thing above all: going without. If you have to pay for your child’s school trip, there is no money left for a new dress or an evening at the theatre. Every bill pushes out another.

A cycle that blocks itself

This is no coincidence. It follows from the basic principle of the market economy. We work, we are paid a wage, and with that wage we buy what other people have mostly made. They, too, depend on selling their goods, because that is the only way the money for their own wages comes in.

When prices rise – for many different reasons, which I will not go into here – this cycle starts to falter. For wages to rise as well, companies would actually have to sell more, because the money for higher wages first has to come in. But people with less money left over buy less. The snake bites its own tail.

For some time now, a war economy financed by huge loans has been called upon to create enough work and wages, but apparently even that is not enough. The question is: what comes next?

Are profits to blame?

Some see the cause in what are sometimes very high corporate profits. From the entrepreneurs’ point of view, however, profit is the reward for a risk that keeps growing as competition increases. They have little reason to give it up.

There is another point: part of these profits flows into pensions through capital investments, and the number of pensioners is growing. Anyone who cuts profits therefore also hits pensions.

Addressing the basic principle

So it is hardly enough to make individual companies more competitive or more sustainable. As long as our provision works only through wages, sales and prices, we remain trapped in this cycle. We need to change the basic principle, and the conditions for doing so have existed for some years now.

The principle of direct provision

Every family shows on a small scale how things could be different: nobody sends their child a bill for dinner. Those who need something are provided for, not those who can pay for it. For my part, I do not immediately feel it as “going without” if I book my holiday in the Canary Islands rather than the Seychelles.

Thanks to worldwide digital networking, this principle could now, for the first time, be conceivable for a whole society:

  • Reporting needs directly: people say what they need, much like placing an order, only without a price.
  • Making what is needed: instead of producing speculatively and then going to great lengths to sell the goods, only what is actually needed gets made. If we do not want weapons, none are made.
  • AI as a tool, not a decision-maker: a neutral artificial intelligence makes needs and capacities visible and helps to coordinate production and transport with as little use of resources as possible. Where something is scarce, people decide, according to democratically agreed rules of priority of the kind we know from medicine and disaster relief.
  • No more pressure to sell: if livelihoods are secured directly, nobody has to sell their labour any more, and no company has to make a profit in order to survive. Wages, prices and sales pressure would lose their basis.

Because individual companies cannot take this step alone under today’s competition, the transition would have to happen jointly and simultaneously. The school trip and the evening at the theatre would then no longer have to compete with each other.

Read more

How such direct provision could work in detail is described in the theses (about a ten-minute read), the detailed report and the free book The Simple Economy.

Join the discussion

I welcome feedback – on the social networks where I share this post, or via the contact page.

← All blog posts

New posts by e-mail

Once a week, on Mondays, a short overview of new posts – free of charge and easy to cancel at any time.

You will first receive an e-mail with a confirmation link. E-mails are sent via Brevo; see the privacy policy for details.

More blog posts

Please spread the word about this idea!